The kitchen overlooks rooftops, then sound, then mountains. Hummingbirds live in the locust tree in back.Well, happy birthday to me. I’ve managed five decades and a bit so far; here’s to many more.
Man, this has been a shitty year in many ways, and one full of life lessons that apparently the universe felt were overdue. Some of those I’m still grappling with. I am so freaking behind on this book it’s not even funny, but thank god for both the wonderful time spent writing in California this summer and the kick in the ass that NaNoWriMo has administered. I’m feeling hopeful about that again and making steady progress.
At the same time among the bumps there’s been plenty of bright spots. Among them my first novel, my first appearance in a Year’s Best collection (edited by Joe Hill, no less), and my first acceptance to longtime goal Magazine of Fantasy and Science Fiction (I have been submitting there for over a decade now). I’ve had nineteen original publications come out since my last birthday, and twelve are currently forthcoming, including a team-up with Mike Resnick. Rachel Swirsky and I are working on some projects together, which is terrific fun. I have a good half dozen stories already spoken for. My collaboration with Bud Sparhawk finally got accepted so he can stop nagging me about why it hasn’t sold yet.
And I’m somehow SFWA President, which is surreal, but also cool because we’ve been getting shit done this year, including admitting independent and small press-published writers, getting a model magazine contract up, reinstating the member electronic newsletter, expanding SFWA’s offerings for self promotion, and even got a cool infographic that answers to all the times someone whinges about how SFWA doesn’t do anything. Not to mention the recent Accessibility Checklist. Nothing speaks like success, and we’ve had some solid ones this year, in my opinion, and I love this ass-kicking team. It’s freaky though, when there’s moments like talking to Harlan Ellison on the phone or getting e-mail from Robert Silverberg.
We moved! Which was awesome but a pain in the butt when it was going on. I love the new place so much; West Seattle feels like home already in a way that Redmond never did. We’re not quuuuuuite moved in all the way; at least, we’re still waiting on a couple of pieces of furniture before everything will feel squared away. And my brother Lowell came out for his first visit to Seattle, but hopefully not the last. I made lots of new friends, and had good times with existing ones, including my beloved Caren Gussoff and Sandra Odell.
As always I picked up some new domestic skills in my endless exploration; this year included how to brew kombucha, how to make Greek yogurt, and the amazing nature of browned butter, which remains me that I co-edited a cookbook with Fran Wilde whose contributors included some pretty august names. Holy smokes was that project a pain in the ass but we survived.
And there’s plenty to look forward to in the next twelve months. Another two-sided collection, hurray! Hearts of Tabat forthcoming, and hopefully Exiles of Tabat along with it. The usual plethora of stories. Continuing to expand the online school (I’ve got some very cool content coming up in 2016.)
So here’s to a lovely birthday weekend that will include Indian buffet and thrift shopping and either ordering myself a pair of shoes I’ve been wanting or pulling a couple of wants from my Amazon wishlist. 😉
Want access to a lively community of writers and readers, free writing classes, co-working sessions, special speakers, weekly writing games, random pictures and MORE for as little as $2? Check out Cat’s Patreon campaign.
Want to get some new fiction? Support my Patreon campaign.
"(On the writing F&SF workshop) Wanted to crow and say thanks: the first story I wrote after taking your class was my very first sale. Coincidence? nah….thanks so much."
When a writer publicly calls someone out, they need to be aware of all of the implications, including the fact that the more popular the writer, the more devastating the results can be, not due to any intrinsic quality of the writer, but the number of fans. The more fans, the more likely it is that the group will contain people who, emboldened by the idea of pleasing a favorite writer, can — and will — go to lengths that go far beyond the norms of civil, and sometimes legal, behavior.
As I’ve said earlier, I have a great deal of respect for Baen and hope it emerges from this watershed moment in a way that suits the bigheartedness of its founder. But in the fray, a lot of writers have been egging their followers on to do shitty things in general, and what has emerged include the above specifics.
It’s not okay to point your readers at someone and basically say “make this person miserable.” It is okay to vote with one’s pocketbook. To not buy the books of people you don’t support. That is called a boycott, and it is an established tactic. (One of my consistent practices throughout the years, though, is to read a book by each one before I make that decision, so I know what I might be missing out on. So far, no regrets.) Going beyond that is, in my opinion, is the act of someone who’s gotten carried away and is no longer seeing their target as a fellow human being, and who needs to stop and think what they are doing.
We have witnessed the results of this tactic when it happens in science fiction. Campaigns contacting employers to complain about posts made in someone’s free time, or even when they’re just suspected to be a particular blogger. People feel free to attack economically or via harassment, ignoring collateral damage in the form of their targets’ families. And let’s not forget SWATting or otherwise attempting to use the police against someone.
Someone started a baseless rumor about Sanford having had a book refused by Baen, and assorted unhinged souls have been running with that one in large and frenzied patterns that spell out “it is possible I am projecting” when seen from above, including repeatedly contacting the Ohio News Media Association to demand that Sanford stop beating his wife explain the allegations.
That one’s bizarre to the point of being more comical than serious, but there’s plenty worse, and that’s because of another phenomena. Free-floating online trolls cluster onto these situations like leeches, doing their best to drive people at best to shut down their social media, at worst to what those trolls see as an ultimate victory: suicide. They’re not in it for politics; they’re in it to feed on the festering hatred being stirred up and to use it as a justification for their own behavior.
I am not overstating things, and anyone who thinks that I am might want to go for a remedial course in Common Sense About the Way Shit is in 2021, as opposed to 40 years ago, which would be when I was first floating around on one of the first message boards. In all sorts of senses, I’ve continued to engage with the world rather than letting someone else moderate it for me, and I don’t know that I had a choice in that but have dealt with a lot of bullshit from people trying to up their visibility in one way or another. I’ve been doxxed so many times it’s lost any scare value. I learned to shoot a gun a couple of years ago because of one doofus sicking his followers on me, and in some situations I carry a taser in my bag. Given some of the stuff that’s happened, it’s not an overreaction.
A person should not have to go to these lengths in order to speak their mind; intimidation aimed at silencing someone overall, rather than a particular platform, is the true damage to free speech. I said it before and will say it again (and again and again, I suspect):
What “if you can’t stand the heat, get out of the kitchen,” aka “people who are too weak should avoid this discourse” says is “only certain people get to speak here.” And that’s shitty, no matter how many noble words you try to dress it up with.
In researching my first two pieces about Sanford’s report and the resultant furor, I talked to a number of people who’d been driven off the Baen discussion boards over the course of the last decade. The most prominent being Mercedes Lackey, who was dogpiled on after she suggested, post 9/11, that maybe unmitigated hatred for Muslims wasn’t the best approach. The posts driving her away came not just from the fans on the boards but some of her fellow authors. [I have removed information here that I believe is either in error or incomplete. See the comments for further info. -Cat]
Lackey had a good bit to say on the subject, including an angle I hadn’t thought of, which is that it can be dangerous to your readers to be pointing them at people:
People these days are crazy. Seriously, dangerously crazy. Crazy enough to send SWAT to someone’s house over a video game (and people have died). Crazy enough to track down your boss and try to get you fired. Crazy enough to show up in person and hurt or kill you or someone you love over an online post. Don’t take my word for it, do a news search.
So suppose you unleash your fans on someone who is that crazy. And he doxxes some of them and SWATS them. At the least they have a broken down door and several hours of horror. At the worst, someone is dead. Or maybe he just tracks the harassment to its source and comes after you. And it’s you that gets SWATTED or fired or has the Drug Cops trashing your house looking to put you in jail.
(I snipped a paragraph here with points covered elsewhere in this piece. -Cat)
The very, very, very best answer to that impulse to send your hordes of minions out to do your bidding? Put your enemy in a story. You’ll get revenge, and better yet, get paid for it.
Lackey also pointed me at this excellent essay on tolerance which has, I think, good points about why groups — including communities formed around discussion groups — cannot contain members attacking other members:
We often forget (or ignore) that no right is absolute, because one person’s rights can conflict with another’s. This is why freedom of speech doesn’t protect extortion, and the right to bear arms doesn’t license armed robbery. Nor is this limited to rights involving the state; people can interfere with each other’s rights with no government involved, as when people use harassment to suppress other people’s speech. While both sides of that example say they are “exercising their free speech,” one of them is using their speech to prevent the other’s: these are not equivalent. The balance of rights has the structure of a peace treaty.
Much of the hoorah has led me to re-examine some beliefs just to make sure I wasn’t crazy, most notably my ideas about professionalism. Professionalism is something I’ve always tried to abide by. It involves a certain amount of dignity and detachedness, and it also requires not throwing verbal lumps of shit at people, particularly colleagues. I dunno, is this old-fashioned? It doesn’t mean not calling out bad behavior, it doesn’t mean I don’t often disagree with others. But I treat them with respect, overall, even when it’s hairy dude-bro looming at me to demand why I don’t do something about some matter that I have nothing to do with, because they are fellow human beings and we are all stuck here on spaceship Earth together.
Being a bad passenger and using your fans to attack a fellow voyager is unprofessional. It gets you known for being unpleasant to work with in any form, because there’s always the worry you may turn it on the person the next seat over. You’re the person that has no qualms about waving live grenades; people don’t want to be around when they don’t know where you’re going to throw it, or even if you’re going to accidentally drop it.
Perhaps a lot of the confusion between professionalism and being “authentic” has to do with the relationship between writers and social media, which can feel mandatory at times. Kacen Callendar notes:
It’s dehumanizing that I or any author should be afraid to speak about our dehumanization, about the boundaries we want and need to set for our health, dehumanizing that we should be scared our work won’t be accepted unless we play along with commodifying ourselves.
When you know that any admission of weakness will be used against you by online trolls, that something like the death of a family member or pet will signal a new barrage of harassment playing on that grief, it becomes even more fraught. And those trolls go for the most vulnerable people — any vulnerability is like blood in the water to them. Can you be authentic and armor yourself at the same time? It takes some maneuvering and a certain amount of don’t-give-a-fuck-ery, and not everyone can do it.
Overall, should any writer cry “release the kraken!” and send these folks after a supposed “enemy”? No. No, and no amount of arguing will ever convince me otherwise. Instead, they should learn to be professional perhaps, because in this heated kitchen, we’re working chefs, not home cooks, and should comport ourselves with a little goddamn dignity.
218 Responses
Cat Rambo: Birthday https://t.co/Jre3ncvH6n
Andy Dustman liked this on Facebook.
Eva Eldridge liked this on Facebook.
Esther Hazleton liked this on Facebook.
John Claude Smith liked this on Facebook.
Jed Hartman liked this on Facebook.
Teri Skultety liked this on Facebook.
Abby Addlepate liked this on Facebook.
Jenna Bird liked this on Facebook.
Martin Å ust liked this on Facebook.
Grayson Bray Morris liked this on Facebook.
Gene Ha liked this on Facebook.
Susan Kuonqui liked this on Facebook.
Mike Conley liked this on Facebook.
Happy Birthday!
Happy birthday to my favorite writer rock star. I adore you and hope your day is blessed and brilliant! <3
Happy Birthday!
Melanie Rambo liked this on Facebook.
Robert Eggleton liked this on Facebook.
Holly Heisey liked this on Facebook.
Dallas Taylor liked this on Facebook.
Bartholomew Klick liked this on Facebook.
Caerwyn Allegra Hawksmoor liked this on Facebook.
Tim Sullivan liked this on Facebook.
Rebecca Senese liked this on Facebook.
Sean Forbes liked this on Facebook.
Shawn Scarber liked this on Facebook.
Patrice Sarath liked this on Facebook.
Neil Clarke liked this on Facebook.
Laurie Jane Adams-Miller liked this on Facebook.
Danielle Myers Gembala liked this on Facebook.
Mike Navratil liked this on Facebook.
John Chu liked this on Facebook.
Carina Bissett liked this on Facebook.
Kim Montgomery Offenburger liked this on Facebook.
@Catrambo Happy Birthday! Enjoy your meal and your shopping!
Happy Birthday, and go you! You’ve accomplished so much!
Happy birthday! Great post!
@Catrambo a very happy birthday to you! May the year ahead be a lovely one.
Christine Daigle liked this on Facebook.
Stephen Gold liked this on Facebook.
Malia Kawaguchi liked this on Facebook.
Michael Capobianco liked this on Facebook.
Jean-Claude Dunyach liked this on Facebook.
Nancy Jane Moore liked this on Facebook.
Joe Mordetsky liked this on Facebook.
Elaine Cunningham liked this on Facebook.
Chris A. Jackson liked this on Facebook.
Happy happy happy 😠Day.
Happy Birthday, Cat!!!!!
The very happiest of birthdays to you!
Happy birthday, Cat!
All due & undue felicitations and a significant number of happy returns.
You did move to that nice apartment. I hope you are enjoying your new place.
Happy Birthday, Cat.
Michael Montoure liked this on Facebook.
Rachael Patterson-McGuire liked this on Facebook.
Matt Hiebert liked this on Facebook.
Matthew M. Foster liked this on Facebook.
Allison Pang liked this on Facebook.
Ross Pattermann liked this on Facebook.
Lisa Troidl Iriarte liked this on Facebook.
Deborah Biancotti liked this on Facebook.
Kelly Szpara liked this on Facebook.
Greg Reid liked this on Facebook.
Stuart Smoot liked this on Facebook.
Susan Isaacs liked this on Facebook.
David Boop liked this on Facebook.
Jeremy Zerfoss liked this on Facebook.
James Sams liked this on Facebook.
Good for you
Thank you for that Accessibility Checklist, and I hope you’re having a great birthday!
Happy birthday!
Happity Happity Joyous Joy on this, your natal remembrance day.
Happy Birthday, Cat! You are a wonderful human being.
Happy Birthday (Why does the universe think we need to learn these things now?)
hoppy bird dayz two ewes and manny moure.
And your mother is cancer free!!!
Happy Birthday!
Jeffrey Lemkin liked this on Facebook.
Brenda Sinclair Sutton liked this on Facebook.
Jennifer Wilson liked this on Facebook.
Kelly Mormann liked this on Facebook.
AP Fuchs liked this on Facebook.
John L. Forrest liked this on Facebook.
Gail Martin liked this on Facebook.
Eileen Wiedbrauk liked this on Facebook.
Roxanne Bland liked this on Facebook.
Vivian Caethe liked this on Facebook.
David Simerly liked this on Facebook.
Cyd Athens liked this on Facebook.
Carrie Cuinn liked this on Facebook.
Michael Samerdyke liked this on Facebook.
Greg Bossert liked this on Facebook.
Lee Whiteside liked this on Facebook.
Jeannette Kathleen Cheney liked this on Facebook.
John Helfers liked this on Facebook.
Bonnie J. Sterling liked this on Facebook.
Julie McGalliard liked this on Facebook.
Melissa Mead liked this on Facebook.
Happy Birthday!
😀 Happy birthday! 🙂
Happy Birthday Cat
And many more. 🙂
Cat –
Sorry to hear about the shit; very glad to hear about all the positive things!
May you have the Happiest of Birthdays, and many, many more!
– JDB
Happy happy birthday!
Happy Birthday!
May next year being all the joy and payoff for all the yuck this year brought.
This has to be a major SF publishing birthday date: you, Beth Meacham, and Moshe Feder, for starts…
Happy Birthday!
Happy birthday, Cat! May it and 365 unbirthdays be very merry this year. 🙂
Happy day Cat!
Teresa Frohock liked this on Facebook.
Christine Maia-Fleres liked this on Facebook.
J Lincoln Fenn liked this on Facebook.
Beth Morris Tanner liked this on Facebook.
Jaime Mayer liked this on Facebook.
Rob Matheny liked this on Facebook.
S. Hutson Blount liked this on Facebook.
Lauren ‘Scribe’ Harris liked this on Facebook.
Gary Westergren liked this on Facebook.
Steven Silver liked this on Facebook.
Rita S. Crossley liked this on Facebook.
Trent Walters liked this on Facebook.
Lori Deason liked this on Facebook.
Stephen Gordon liked this on Facebook.
Lettie Prell liked this on Facebook.
Alexander M. Osias liked this on Facebook.
Bob Angell liked this on Facebook.
Maureen Smith liked this on Facebook.
Keith Whitemore liked this on Facebook.
Lynn Flewelling liked this on Facebook.
Laura Perkinson Graham liked this on Facebook.
Amy Wolf liked this on Facebook.
Sharon Joss liked this on Facebook.
Elizabeth Crowens liked this on Facebook.
John V. Hedtke liked this on Facebook.
John McColley liked this on Facebook.
Mimi Williams liked this on Facebook.
Elizabeth Bourne liked this on Facebook.
Roberta Gregory liked this on Facebook.
Ryan Nellis liked this on Facebook.
Tamara Vining liked this on Facebook.
Alyx Dellamonica liked this on Facebook.
Dora Badger liked this on Facebook.
LX Cain liked this on Facebook.
From one Kat to another Cat, happy birthday!
Happy cake day!
Happy many more birthdays!!
Happy birthday to you, indeed!
Happy Birthday. Wishing you a creative and successful year.
Happy Birthday!
THIS A REAL CAKE?!! I’ll eat it, even though I’m not a cake person…!
Happy Birthday
Deirdre Saoirse Moen liked this on Facebook.
Anthea Sharp liked this on Facebook.
Andie Whitewing liked this on Facebook.
Ralph Ambrose liked this on Facebook.
Rashida Scholz liked this on Facebook.
Stina Leicht liked this on Facebook.
Stephen McCracken liked this on Facebook.
Danika Dinsmore liked this on Facebook.
Laura J Mixon liked this on Facebook.
Sheila Oranch liked this on Facebook.
Steve Pantazis liked this on Facebook.
Paul Rodes liked this on Facebook.
JoAnn Chapa liked this on Facebook.
James Nicoll liked this on Facebook.
Kat Tanaka Okopnik liked this on Facebook.
Happy Birthday, Cat!
A wonderful report. Happy Birthday, Cat!
Happy Birthday, Cat! 🙂
Happy Birthday! Celebrate well.
Happy birthday to one of my favorite authors!
Katrina Marier liked this on Facebook.
Elyn Selu liked this on Facebook.
Kris Saknussemm liked this on Facebook.
Earl Cooley III liked this on Facebook.
Veronica Sicoe liked this on Facebook.
Sherri Stewart liked this on Facebook.
Kira Franz liked this on Facebook.
Fragano Ledgister liked this on Facebook.
Lisa Mantchev liked this on Facebook.
Joy Johnson liked this on Facebook.
Ginger Jackson liked this on Facebook.
Amanda Fitch liked this on Facebook.
Miriah Hetherington liked this on Facebook.
Sarah Jennings liked this on Facebook.
Allan Gilbreath liked this on Facebook.
Melanie Meadors liked this on Facebook.
Ross Brown liked this on Facebook.
Rudi Dornemann liked this on Facebook.
Dave Robison liked this on Facebook.
Jody Lynn Nye liked this on Facebook.
William C. Dietz liked this on Facebook.
Chris Furst liked this on Facebook.
Pete Cook liked this on Facebook.
Aurelio Rico Lopez III liked this on Facebook.
Karen Elizabeth Sullivan liked this on Facebook.
Tony Peak liked this on Facebook.
Fran Friel liked this on Facebook.
Michelle Ristuccia liked this on Facebook.
Martha Allard liked this on Facebook.
Fábio Fernandes liked this on Facebook.
Lewis A. Sellers liked this on Facebook.
JG Faherty liked this on Facebook.
Happy birthday, Cat. And many more!
Happy Birthday, Cat xx
Justina LA Robson liked this on Facebook.
Fran Stewart liked this on Facebook.
Rhonda Parrish liked this on Facebook.
Kim Ross liked this on Facebook.
Richard Chwedyk liked this on Facebook.
John Goodwin liked this on Facebook.
David Farland liked this on Facebook.
Beverly Arnold liked this on Facebook.
Happy Birthday to YOU!
Aelle Ables liked this on Facebook.